Compare damage you can use this turn

Assume base cards, no Strength, Accuracy or other modifiers, enough hand space for every Shiv and a target without Block or hit reactions. Play all generated Shivs.

CardFirst costImmediate damage
Leading Strike1 Energy3 + 4 + 4 = 11
Blade Dance1 Energy4 + 4 + 4 = 12
Up My Sleeve2 Energy4 + 4 + 4 = 12
Snakebite2 Energy0; applies 7 Poison

Leading Strike is itself an Attack. Blade Dance and Up My Sleeve are Skills whose Shivs supply the attacks. Kusarigama can add six damage after three Attacks in one turn. Letter Opener counts Blade Dance and Up My Sleeve as Skill plays; their Shivs add nothing to its count.

Up My Sleeve reduces its own cost after being played, so the first-cycle comparison is not its whole value. Blade Dance Exhausts; Up My Sleeve can return in a later reshuffle. A short hallway fight may end before the cheaper repeat matters.

Take a damage solution before more draw

A reward that supplies damage now can solve a weak opening without committing the deck to Shivs. Adding Acrobatics to a deck of basic attacks finds more basic attacks while spending Energy. Once stronger cards and discard payoffs exist, the same draw becomes more useful.

The November 12 discussion describes repeatedly waiting for Poison support and dying before the first elite. Judge the next reward against the enemies on the route. Preserve enough Block to survive when the damage does not reach lethal.

Keep a second answer for hit reactions

Many small hits are costly against Skulking Colony’s Personal Hive. Poison supplies damage without repeatedly creating player attack hits. That can justify Snakebite alongside Shivs even when Blade Dance is better against a low-HP ordinary enemy. The Shiv strategy covers its scaling and defensive costs; the Poison strategy covers longer fights.

JapaneseExport’s reward comparison

In the November 7 coaching session with Fitz, the offered cards include Expertise, Blade Dance and Snakebite. Around 15:40, JapaneseExport recommends Blade Dance for its one-Energy immediate damage and the number of later payoffs it can use.

The recording is Ascension 10 on beta v0.111.0. Expertise there draws two cards and grants them Retain, the same text main has had since v0.111.1; the earlier v0.107.1 card drew up to six cards. The table above uses card values from the version labelled beside it.