Base Apparition is Ethereal and Exhausts when played, so an unplayed copy is lost for the combat at turn end. Upgrading removes Ethereal but keeps Exhaust and adds no Retain: an unplayed Apparition+ is discarded and can be drawn again, while a played one is still gone. Well-Laid Plans can Retain a copy past turn end.

Intangible reduces each damage or HP-loss instance to 1 for the turn. Against several hits that still costs several HP, while Lucky Tonic’s Buffer stops one HP-loss event entirely. Neither restores HP.